Skip to content
Menu

I’ve Already Instructed a Solicitor or Claims Company for Car Finance Redress, What Are My Options

If you signed up with a solicitor or claims-management company before the FCA motor-finance redress scheme became clear, you may now be wondering why you need them when the official route is free.

If you signed up with a solicitor or claims-management company before the FCA motor-finance redress scheme became clear, you may now be wondering why you need them when the official route is free.

Do not assume that the FCA scheme automatically cancels your existing contract. The redress process and the agreement you signed with your representative are separate questions.

The sensible first step is to understand exactly what you agreed to.

Get the contract and fee terms

Ask for a copy of the retainer, terms and conditions and any authority you signed.

Identify:

• the fee or percentage payable if redress is obtained;• whether VAT is additional;• any cancellation or termination charges;• what happens if you deal directly with the lender;• whether the representative has already submitted a complaint; and• what work they say they will continue to provide.

Do not rely only on what you remember from an online sign-up journey.

The official FCA route is free

Consumers can complain directly to lenders without paying a representative.

That fact may be relevant to what you decide now, but it does not by itself determine whether your existing agreement can be ended without cost.

If you want to cancel, ask the firm in writing what contractual provision they rely on for any proposed charge and request a clear calculation.

What if I signed online or by telephone?

Consumer-contract rules can sometimes provide cancellation rights, including cooling-off rights, but whether they apply and whether the period has expired depends on the agreement and circumstances.

Do not rely on a generic internet claim that there is a “loophole” allowing every motor-finance client to walk away.

If the sums are significant or the contractual position is disputed, independent legal or consumer advice may be worthwhile.

What if I am unhappy with the service?

A disagreement about fees is different from a complaint about service, although they can overlap.

Use the firm’s complaints procedure and explain precisely what you dispute. Depending on whether the business is a solicitor or regulated claims-management company, different regulatory and ombudsman routes may apply.

Keep copies of correspondence and avoid cancelling direct debits or ignoring demands without understanding the contractual consequences.

What about the current legal challenge to the FCA scheme?

Parts of the scheme remain suspended following the Upper Tribunal order of 2 July 2026.

That makes it even more important to distinguish between what your representative is contractually obliged to do and what the lender can currently do under the scheme.

Ask the representative for a factual update rather than accepting vague statements that the case is “with the FCA” or “awaiting compensation”.

Make the decision on information, not irritation

You may ultimately decide to keep the representative, end the agreement, challenge a fee or seek independent advice.

The aim of this guide is not to push you towards cancellation. It is to make sure you understand that the free official redress route and your private contract are two different things.

If the uncertainty is causing anxiety, deal with the contract question separately from the emotional impact. Counselling can support the latter; it cannot interpret the contract for you.

Questions to ask your representative now

A short written list of questions can turn a vague worry into information you can act on. You might ask:

  • Which lenders have you complained to on my behalf, and when?
  • Have any lenders replied, and can I see copies?
  • What work have you done on my case so far?
  • What would you do from here that I could not easily do myself?
  • What fee would I pay if redress is paid through the FCA scheme?
  • What would I owe if I ended the agreement today, and how is that worked out?

Ask for the answers in writing. A clear reply helps you compare options. A vague or evasive reply is also useful information.

Putting your decision in writing

Whatever you decide, write to the firm rather than relying on a phone call. Keep the message factual. State your name, any reference number, what you are asking for and the date.

If you want to end the agreement, say so clearly and ask the firm to confirm, in writing, any amount it says you owe and the clause it relies on. If you want to stay but need better communication, say what you need, such as an update at agreed intervals.

Keep copies of everything you send and receive in one place.

If the lender contacts you directly

Under the scheme, lenders may write to customers about their agreements. If you have a representative, you may receive letters yourself, or they may go to the firm, depending on what authority you gave.

Do not ignore a letter from your lender. Read it, keep it, and if you are represented, tell the firm you have received it. If you are unsure whether a message is genuine, contact the lender using details from its official website rather than any number in the message.

Where to complain if you cannot resolve a dispute

Always start with the firm’s own complaints procedure. If that does not resolve things, the next step depends on who you instructed.

  • Claims management companies are authorised by the FCA, and complaints about them can usually go to the Financial Ombudsman Service.
  • Solicitors in England and Wales: complaints about service can usually go to the Legal Ombudsman. Concerns about professional conduct can be reported to the Solicitors Regulation Authority.
  • Solicitors in Scotland: complaints usually go to the Scottish Legal Complaints Commission.

Each body has its own rules about time limits and what it can look at, so check its website before you refer a complaint.

Free advice on the contract

Citizens Advice can help you understand consumer rights and what to do next. If the sums involved are significant, a solicitor who is not connected to the firm you instructed can give independent advice on the agreement itself.

If you feel foolish or angry

Many people signed up with a representative because the process looked complicated, adverts made it seem necessary or they were busy at the time. That was a reasonable decision based on what you knew then.

If the situation is affecting your sleep, mood or relationships, talk to your GP, or in England refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies. If you are struggling to cope, Samaritans are available free on 116 123 at any time.

Last reviewed

5 September 2026

Important informationThis guide provides general information and is not intended to provide legal, financial, medical or other professional advice. Individual circumstances can be different. You may wish to check current information from official sources and seek advice from an appropriately qualified professional before making important decisions.