I Think I Chose the Wrong Solicitor or Claims Company, What Can I Do
Regretting who you instructed does not necessarily mean you need to cancel immediately.
Regretting who you instructed does not necessarily mean you need to cancel immediately.
Sometimes the problem is poor communication that can be fixed. Sometimes expectations were unrealistic. Sometimes the service or charging information genuinely gives cause for concern.
The useful first step is to identify what is actually wrong before deciding what to do about it.
What is making you doubt the choice?
Try to name the problem.
Is nobody returning calls? Do you not know who handles the case? Were deductions different from what you expected? Do you feel pressured to accept an offer? Has the firm failed to explain a free direct route? Are you simply frustrated because the claim is taking longer than expected?
Different problems need different responses.
Ask for a proper case and costs update
Request:
• the current stage of the matter;• outstanding evidence or decisions;• who has the next action;• the next expected milestone;• an up-to-date costs position;• the deductions that could apply if successful; and• a copy of the agreement and any insurance documentation.
A clear written update may either restore confidence or confirm that the problem is more serious.
Check who actually regulates the business
A solicitor’s firm should appear on the SRA’s records where it is SRA-regulated.
Claims-management companies carrying on regulated claims-management activity may instead be regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority.
The protections, complaints routes and professional obligations can differ. Do not assume that a website using legal language is itself a solicitors’ practice.
Raise the concern before making a rushed move
If the problem is service, use the firm’s complaints procedure.
Explain what happened, what information is missing and what you want them to do. Keep the complaint factual.
If it cannot be resolved, the Legal Ombudsman may deal with eligible complaints about legal service providers, while regulatory concerns can be reported to the appropriate regulator. These routes serve different purposes.
Can I move the case elsewhere?
Potentially, yes.
Another solicitor may be willing to take over, but first understand the existing funding agreement, accrued costs, disbursements and how the file would be transferred.
Ask the prospective new solicitor what they think of the merits and funding before ending the first retainer. Otherwise you could terminate one arrangement and discover that nobody else is prepared to run the claim on the same basis.
What if the real problem is the claim itself?
Sometimes dissatisfaction with the representative is actually disappointment with the evidence.
A solicitor may tell you liability is weak, medical evidence does not support the expected value or an offer is reasonable. Unwelcome advice is not automatically poor service.
Ask them to explain the reasoning and evidence. If the decision is significant, a second legal opinion may be appropriate.
Do not let the dispute consume you
A conflict with a solicitor or claims company can become another source of anxiety on top of the original accident or redress issue.
Deal with it methodically: information, complaint if necessary, independent advice where justified, then a decision.
Counselling can support the emotional impact of feeling trapped or mistrustful, but it should not be used to steer you towards a particular legal provider.
Keep a simple record
When you are unhappy with how a claim is being handled, it helps to have the facts in one place.
Keep a note of:
- the date you signed up and what you were told at the time
- copies of the agreement, terms and any letters or emails
- calls you made, who you spoke to and what was said
- requests you made that were not answered
- any figures you were given about costs or deductions
This does not need to be elaborate. A notebook or a single document is enough. It will make any complaint clearer and can stop the problem going round in circles in your head.
How to write a complaint that gets a proper answer
A complaint is more likely to be dealt with properly if it is clear and calm.
- Address it to the person named in the firm’s complaints procedure, if there is one.
- Give your name, any reference number and the type of claim.
- Set out what has gone wrong, with dates where you can.
- Say what you would like to happen, such as a full update, a named contact, an explanation of charges or a corrected bill.
- Ask them to confirm they have received it and tell you when you can expect a response.
Keep a copy of everything you send. Email is often easiest because it gives you a dated record.
Where can a complaint go next?
If the firm does not resolve your complaint, there may be an independent route.
The Legal Ombudsman looks at eligible service complaints about lawyers in England and Wales. You usually need to complain to the firm first. There are time limits for taking a complaint to the Legal Ombudsman, so check the current rules on their website rather than waiting.
Complaints about claims management companies regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority can usually be taken to the Financial Ombudsman Service once the company has had the chance to respond. Again, check their website for current time limits.
If your solicitor or claims company is based in Scotland or Northern Ireland, the routes can be different. Check mygov.scot or nidirect for where to start.
If you feel you were pressured into signing
Some people sign up after an unexpected call, text or approach, or at a time when they were injured, grieving or stressed.
If you feel you were rushed, misled or not given clear information about costs, include this in your complaint and say exactly what happened. You may also be able to report concerns to the relevant regulator.
Depending on how and when you signed, you may have had a right to cancel. Check your agreement and get advice from Citizens Advice or another solicitor if you are not sure where you stand.
Before you sign up with someone new
If you decide to move, try not to repeat the pressure of the first decision. Before agreeing to anything:
- check the firm on the relevant regulator’s register
- ask who will actually handle your case and how they will keep you updated
- ask for the costs and deductions to be explained in writing, in plain English
- ask what will happen to the costs owed to your current representative
- take time to read the agreement, and ask questions about anything you do not understand
A good firm should be willing to answer these questions without pressuring you to sign straight away.
Looking after yourself through it
Feeling that you made the wrong choice can bring up guilt, anger and worry, especially if the claim relates to an accident, a loss or a difficult time in your life.
Try to remember that many people choose a representative quickly, when they are under strain. Making a choice that did not work out is not a failing.
If the situation is affecting your sleep, mood or ability to cope, speak to your GP. In England, you can also refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies. If you are finding things very hard or having thoughts of harming yourself, call Samaritans free on 116 123, any time. In an emergency, call 999.
Last reviewed
5 September 2026
Important informationThis guide provides general information and is not intended to provide legal, financial, medical or other professional advice. Individual circumstances can be different. You may wish to check current information from official sources and seek advice from an appropriately qualified professional before making important decisions.
