Conditional Fee Agreements and Damages-Based Agreements, What’s the Difference
A Conditional Fee Agreement and a Damages-Based Agreement can both be described as “no win, no fee”, but they calculate payment differently.
A Conditional Fee Agreement and a Damages-Based Agreement can both be described as “no win, no fee”, but they calculate payment differently.
That difference matters because two firms can use the same headline phrase while offering contracts with different financial consequences.
The safest way to compare them is to ignore the marketing label for a moment and ask how the representative’s payment is actually calculated.
How does a Conditional Fee Agreement work?
Under a CFA, the solicitor’s entitlement to some or all of their fee depends on the outcome defined in the agreement.
If the case succeeds, the solicitor can receive their base costs and may charge a success fee. In personal-injury cases, the success fee paid by the client is capped at 25% of specified damages, excluding damages for future care and loss.
The success fee is an uplift on the solicitor’s costs. It is not simply another name for owning 25% of the claim.
How is a DBA different?
Under a DBA, payment is calculated by reference to a percentage of the financial benefit recovered when the contractual success criteria are met.
The agreement should state the percentage and explain what is included within it.
Different legal areas are subject to different rules and caps, so do not take a percentage quoted for one type of case and assume it applies to another.
Why can the final figures still be confusing?
Because the headline percentage may not tell you everything.
You may need to understand VAT, disbursements, insurance premiums, costs recovered from the opponent and how any recovered costs interact with what you owe your own representative.
SRA guidance requires solicitors to provide clear, accurate information about charging arrangements and to explain the circumstances in which additional costs may arise.
A worked example is more useful than a slogan
Suppose somebody tells you their fee is “25%”.
Ask them to show, in pounds and pence, what happens if £20,000 is recovered.
What is the solicitor’s fee? Is VAT already included? Is an insurance premium additional? Are any disbursements deducted? What amount would actually reach your bank account?
Then ask the same question for an unsuccessful claim and for a claim you decide to end early.
Which is better?
There is no universal answer.
The suitability of a funding arrangement depends on the case, risk, likely work, other available funding and the terms being offered.
Before entering either arrangement, also check whether legal-expenses insurance, trade-union assistance, a statutory scheme or a free direct process could fund or resolve the issue differently.
Do not compare only the percentage
Price matters, but so do expertise, communication, case handling and contractual flexibility.
A lower headline percentage may not be better if other charges are added. A higher price is not automatically justified by a claim that a firm will obtain more compensation.
Compare the whole agreement and the service, not just the advert.
What happens to the other side’s costs if I lose?
This is a separate question from what you pay your own representative, and it is easy to overlook.
In many types of court case in England and Wales, the losing side can be ordered to pay some of the winning side’s legal costs. In most personal injury claims, a rule known as qualified one-way costs shifting generally protects claimants from paying the other side’s costs if they lose. There are exceptions, for example where a claim is found to be fundamentally dishonest.
Outside personal injury, the position can be quite different. Ask your representative directly what you could owe the other side if the case fails.
What is after the event insurance?
Some representatives recommend an insurance policy taken out after the problem has arisen, often called after the event or ATE insurance.
Depending on the policy, it may cover costs such as expert reports, court fees or the other side’s costs if the claim is unsuccessful. The premium may only be payable if you win and may then be deducted from your compensation.
Ask what the policy covers, what it does not cover, how much the premium is likely to be and who pays it in each outcome. Check whether you already have legal expenses cover through home, car or other insurance before agreeing to buy a new policy.
What if the agreement ends early?
“No win, no fee” does not always mean you pay nothing if the claim does not reach a successful outcome.
Many agreements explain what happens if you end the agreement, stop cooperating, refuse to accept advice about a reasonable settlement offer or mislead your representative. In some of these situations you could be asked to pay for work already done.
Read these sections carefully and ask for them to be explained in plain language before you sign.
Why can deductions matter more in smaller claims?
In some lower-value claims, fewer of your legal costs can be recovered from the other side. That can mean a larger share of the deductions comes out of your compensation.
If your claim is likely to be modest, ask how much you would realistically keep and whether a simpler route, such as a direct complaint or an ombudsman scheme, might be more suitable.
Questions to ask before you sign
- Is this a Conditional Fee Agreement, a Damages-Based Agreement or another type of arrangement?
- What exactly counts as a win under this agreement?
- What is the most I could pay if I win, and is VAT included?
- What could I pay if I lose, or if the agreement ends early?
- Will I need insurance, and what will it cost?
- Who will actually work on my case, and how will they keep me updated?
- Can I have a written estimate of what I might receive in different outcomes?
A reputable firm should be willing to answer these questions clearly. Take the agreement away to read it if you can, and do not feel pressured to sign on the spot.
Do the same rules apply across the UK?
The rules described here mainly relate to England and Wales.
Scotland has its own arrangements, including what are called success fee agreements, and different rules on legal expenses. Northern Ireland also has its own rules. If you live outside England and Wales, ask a solicitor qualified in your part of the UK how funding works there.
What if I am unhappy with how I have been charged?
Raise your concern with the firm first and ask for a copy of its complaints procedure.
If you are not satisfied with the response from a solicitor, you may be able to take your complaint to the Legal Ombudsman. Concerns about a solicitor’s professional conduct can be reported to the Solicitors Regulation Authority. If you used a claims management company, complaints can usually go to the Financial Ombudsman Service once the firm has had the chance to respond.
Looking after yourself during a claim
Legal claims often follow an injury, loss or other difficult experience, and the paperwork can add to the stress. If the process is affecting your sleep, mood or ability to cope, speak to your GP.
If you are in distress, you can call Samaritans free at any time on 116 123.
Last reviewed
5 September 2026
Important informationThis guide provides general information and is not intended to provide legal, financial, medical or other professional advice. Individual circumstances can be different. You may wish to check current information from official sources and seek advice from an appropriately qualified professional before making important decisions.
