I Need a Hire or Replacement Car After an Accident That Wasn’t My Fault, What Are My Options
When your car is suddenly unusable, the urgent problem may not be the repair. It may be getting children to school tomorrow, reaching work, visiting somebody you care for or attending medical appointments.
When your car is suddenly unusable, the urgent problem may not be the repair. It may be getting children to school tomorrow, reaching work, visiting somebody you care for or attending medical appointments.
That urgency can make any offer of a replacement vehicle sound simple. It is worth slowing down long enough to understand what is actually being offered, who is providing it and what agreement you are entering into.
Start with your own insurance position
Ask your insurer what your policy provides. A courtesy car, replacement vehicle or hire provision can depend on the policy wording, repair arrangements and whether your car is repairable.
If another driver appears responsible, their insurer may also contact you or make proposals. You can ask for those proposals in writing and understand what accepting them would mean.
The fact that an accident was not your fault does not make every replacement-car arrangement automatically free or risk-free.
Courtesy car, ordinary hire and credit hire are not necessarily the same
A courtesy car may be provided under an insurance or repair arrangement. An ordinary hire vehicle is usually hired on agreed payment terms.
Credit hire is different: a vehicle may be supplied on credit while the provider seeks to recover the charges from the at-fault party or insurer. That can be useful in appropriate circumstances, but it is a contract. Questions about need, rate, duration, responsibility and the claimant’s financial circumstances can become relevant.
Before signing, ask plainly:
• Who is the contracting party?• What is the daily or total rate?• Who is expected to pay?• What happens if responsibility for the accident is disputed?• Could I ever become liable for some or all of the charges?• What information am I agreeing to provide?• When must the vehicle be returned?
Do not be embarrassed to ask. “Replacement car” describes what you receive, not necessarily the legal arrangement underneath it.
Think about what transport you actually need
A replacement vehicle should solve a genuine transport problem.
Someone who needs seven seats for children has a different requirement from somebody who can manage temporarily with public transport. A disabled driver may need adaptations. A self-employed person may rely on a particular type of vehicle for work.
Keep a short record of why transport is needed and any additional reasonable travel costs. That can be more useful than trying to reconstruct the disruption later.
What if my own car is on finance?
A damaged car and its finance agreement are separate issues. Continue to understand your contractual obligations rather than assuming payments stop because the vehicle is off the road.
If the car is declared a total loss, compare the insurer’s settlement information with the outstanding finance position. If there is a shortfall, check whether you have relevant additional cover, such as GAP insurance, and read its terms.
This can be an unexpectedly stressful part of an accident because you may be discussing the value of a car while still needing transport and recovering from the collision.
The pressure to sort transport can affect wellbeing too
Transport is closely connected with independence. Losing it overnight can make somebody feel trapped, particularly in rural areas or where work, caring or medical appointments depend on a car.
If the paperwork feels overwhelming, write down the immediate transport need first, then the insurance question, then any contractual question about a hire vehicle. They do not all have to be solved in the same phone call.
If the wider accident is affecting your mental wellbeing, counselling or talking support can sit alongside the practical work. It does not need to be connected to a compensation claim.
What to do in the first few days
You do not have to sort everything at once, but a few early steps can make the transport question easier.
- Report the accident to your own insurer as your policy requires, even if you believe the other driver was at fault.
- Keep the other driver’s details, their insurer if known, and any police or claim reference numbers together in one place.
- Ask your insurer or repairer where the car is, whether it is safe to drive and roughly what happens next.
- Write down the journeys you cannot cover without a car this week, so you can explain your need clearly.
If a call or message asks you to agree something quickly, it is reasonable to say you will think about it and call back.
If several companies contact you
After an accident, people are sometimes contacted by insurers, hire companies, claims management companies or solicitors, occasionally before they have had time to think. Some of these contacts may be legitimate. Others may be unsolicited and pushy.
You are not obliged to accept the first offer you hear. Ask who the caller represents, how they got your details and whether they can put their proposal in writing. Do not sign anything at the roadside or while you are in pain, shaken or distracted.
If you are thinking about using a claims management company, you can check that it is authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority. Solicitors in England and Wales are regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority. Checking takes a few minutes and can protect you from a poor arrangement.
Looking after a hire or replacement vehicle
When you collect a replacement car, it helps to treat it with the same care you would any borrowed property.
- Check any existing damage with the provider and take dated photographs before you drive away.
- Ask what insurance applies to the vehicle, whether there is an excess and who to call if it breaks down or is damaged.
- Check whether there are mileage limits, restrictions on who can drive it or rules about taking it abroad.
- Keep the paperwork in the car and a copy at home.
Ask when the hire is expected to end. It is often linked to your own car being repaired or a total-loss settlement being paid, so knowing the likely end point lets you plan ahead rather than being caught without transport.
If your car is leased or provided through a scheme
If your car is leased, a company car or provided through a scheme such as Motability, contact the provider early. The agreement may include its own accident reporting process and replacement vehicle arrangements, and it may set out who must be told before repairs begin.
A self-employed person who relies on a van or specialist vehicle may need to explain that a standard car would not let them keep working. Be specific about what the work involves.
If you are unhappy with how an insurer is handling things
Start by raising the problem directly with the insurer and asking for its complaints process. Keep notes of calls, including dates and names.
If the complaint is not resolved, you may be able to take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service, which handles complaints about financial businesses including insurers. Citizens Advice can also help you understand your options and what to say.
Feeling nervous about driving a different car
Some people find that getting behind the wheel of an unfamiliar car soon after an accident brings up more anxiety than they expected. Different controls, a different size of car or simply the memory of the collision can all play a part.
Take a few minutes to adjust the seat and mirrors and get familiar with the controls before setting off. Start with a short, familiar route if you can. If fear about driving is lasting or getting worse, speak to your GP. In England, you can also refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies for help with anxiety.
Important informationThis guide provides general information and is not intended to provide legal, financial, medical or other professional advice. Individual circumstances can be different. You may wish to check current information from official sources and seek advice from an appropriately qualified professional before making important decisions.
