Challenging Unhelpful Thoughts
Thoughts can feel convincing simply because they appear quickly or repeatedly.
Thoughts can feel convincing simply because they appear quickly or repeatedly.
This exercise helps you pause and examine a thought rather than automatically treating it as a fact.
Step 1 – catch the thought
Choose one specific situation where your mood changed.
Write down the thought that went through your mind. For example, after making a mistake you might think, ‘I always get everything wrong.’
Step 2 – name the feeling
What did the thought leave you feeling: anxious, embarrassed, low, angry or something else?
This helps you see the link between the situation, interpretation and emotional response.
Step 3 – check the evidence
Ask what genuinely supports the thought and what does not.
Try to use facts rather than feelings. Feeling like a failure is not, by itself, evidence that you fail at everything.
Step 4 – look for other explanations
Could there be another way to understand what happened?
What would you say to somebody you care about if they had the same thought?
Step 5 – create a more balanced thought
The replacement does not need to be unrealistically positive.
‘I made one mistake and I can correct it’ is often more believable and useful than ‘Everything is amazing.’
Step 6 – notice what changes
Check how you feel after considering the more balanced view.
The emotion may not disappear. The aim is greater flexibility, not forcing yourself to feel positive.
Use the exercise selectively
You do not need to challenge every thought you have.
It is most useful for recurring thoughts that intensify anxiety, low mood or avoidance. If a thought points to a real practical problem, combine reflection with appropriate action.
Why thoughts can feel like facts
Many thoughts arrive automatically. They pop into your head in a split second, often as a short sentence or an image, and they can feel true before you have had any chance to question them.
When you are anxious, low, tired or stressed, these automatic thoughts tend to become harsher and more certain. A thought like “they think I’m useless” can feel obvious, even when there is little evidence for it.
This exercise is based on ideas used in cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT). It does not ask you to stop thinking. It asks you to notice that a thought is one possible interpretation, not the only one.
Common thinking traps to look out for
Some patterns of thinking come up again and again. Learning to recognise them can make the exercise quicker, because you start to spot the pattern as it happens.
- All-or-nothing thinking: seeing things as total success or total failure, with nothing in between.
- Catastrophising: jumping to the worst possible outcome and treating it as likely.
- Mind reading: assuming you know what someone else is thinking about you.
- Overgeneralising: taking one event and turning it into “always” or “never”.
- Labelling: calling yourself a name such as “idiot” or “failure” instead of describing what happened.
- Discounting the positive: deciding that good things do not count or were just luck.
- Emotional reasoning: believing something must be true because it feels true.
- Should statements: holding yourself to rigid rules about how you ought to be.
You do not need to name the trap perfectly. Simply noticing “this sounds like mind reading” can loosen the thought’s grip.
Questions to help you test a thought
If you get stuck at the evidence stage, these questions can help:
- Am I confusing a feeling with a fact?
- Is there anything I am ignoring because it does not fit the thought?
- Have I been in a similar situation before? What actually happened?
- If this thought is partly true, how much of it is true?
- How will I see this in a week, a month or a year?
- What is the most likely outcome, rather than the worst one?
- Is this thought helping me deal with the situation, or keeping me stuck?
A worked example
Imagine you sent a message to a friend and they have not replied all day.
The thought might be: “They’re ignoring me. I must have upset them.” The feeling might be anxiety and a sinking sense of rejection.
Evidence for the thought might be that they usually reply sooner. Evidence against might be that your last conversation was friendly, they have mentioned being busy at work, and they have been slow to reply before without anything being wrong.
A more balanced thought might be: “They might be busy. I don’t know that I’ve upset them. If I’m still worried tomorrow, I can ask.”
The anxiety may not vanish, but it is likely to feel more manageable, and you have a sensible next step.
Writing it down helps
It is much harder to examine a thought that stays in your head, because it tends to go round in circles.
Many people use a simple written record with headings for the situation, the thought, the feeling, the evidence for and against, and the balanced thought. A notebook or a note on your phone is enough.
Try to fill it in as soon as you can after the moment, while you still remember what went through your mind. Over a few weeks, you may start to see which thoughts and situations come up most often.
If the exercise feels hard or does not seem to work
It is common to find this difficult at first. Like most skills, it usually gets easier with practice.
You may not believe the balanced thought straight away. That is normal. Try rating how much you believe the original thought before and after, for example out of 10. A small drop is still progress.
If you are very upset, it can be hard to think clearly enough to do this. In that moment, a calming activity such as slow breathing or a short walk may help more. You can come back to the thought later.
If the exercise starts to feel like arguing with yourself or blaming yourself for your thoughts, step back. The aim is to be curious and fair with yourself, not critical.
When to look for more support
If unhelpful thoughts are frequent, distressing or affecting your sleep, work or relationships, talking to someone trained can help.
In England, you can refer yourself to NHS Talking Therapies for common problems such as anxiety and depression, and CBT is one of the therapies offered. You can also speak to your GP, wherever you live in the UK.
If your thoughts include harming yourself or ending your life, please get help now. Call Samaritans free on 116 123 at any time, contact NHS 111 for urgent advice, or call 999 if you are in immediate danger.
1.6: Why Does My Mind Keep Thinking the Worst?
11.3: Creating a Worry Diary
11.12: Mental Wellbeing Check-In
General information only. This is not a diagnosis or a substitute for professional healthcare advice.
