Skip to content
Menu

The Rural Hub

Working with family on the farm: handling everyday disagreements

When family farm work keeps ending in an argument, focus on one recurring problem. Practical prompts for clearer work decisions, time away from routine farm talk and finding support outside the disagreement.

Two adult farmers talking over mugs of tea in a stone farm courtyard.

When working with family on the farm keeps ending in an argument, start with one recurring disagreement and a separate time to discuss it. The NHS suggests returning to a difficult conversation when everyone is calmer, rather than trying to push through while tempers are high.[1]

You might be arguing about changed instructions, who answers weekend calls or whether a discussion can wait until morning. The prompts below are for everyday disagreements where people feel safe to speak. They are not counselling, legal advice or a way to manage abuse.

Name the work problem without judging the person

Choose a recent, specific example. Instead of “You never listen”, try “Yesterday I arranged the feed delivery, then discovered the time had been changed. Can we agree who tells the supplier?” This is suggested wording, not a real family’s story or a promise that the conversation will go well.

Write down what happened, what you understood and what needs deciding now. Leave guesses about motives out of your opening. Ask the other person how they understood the same event. NHS guidance recommends checking your understanding by reflecting back what someone has said or asking for clarification.[1]

Keep this discussion about the delivery, rather than trying to settle every old disagreement. If ownership or succession comes up, note it as a separate subject needing its own conversation and, where appropriate, professional advice. A decision about tomorrow’s feed order does not settle anyone’s future on the farm.

Give farm decisions somewhere to go

Suggest a short, agreed slot for routine work questions. Ask what would suit the people involved and where they could speak without an audience. Avoid starting a family argument beside moving machinery, during livestock handling or while somebody is driving.

Try using that slot to answer one operational question: who confirms a changed job, and how does everyone affected hear about it? You could agree that the person changing a collection time contacts the driver and the person expecting them. Check that each person has accepted their part rather than assigning work to someone absent.

If several relatives send different instructions, ask for one agreed contact for that task. Keep the arrangement visible to those doing the work. You could put the contact’s name beside the task in the work diary and agree when somebody else takes over. Leave room for people to raise a problem with the arrangement.

Agree what can wait until tomorrow

The Mental Health Foundation describes boundaries as including what people appreciate and need, such as time alone, rather than only what they dislike.[2] On your farm, that might mean asking for supper without routine work discussions or an evening when another agreed person takes non-urgent messages.

Be concrete about the request. “Could we keep supplier queries for the morning?” is easier to discuss than “The farm takes over everything.” Ask what genuinely needs an immediate response and what can be written down for the next work conversation. Do not silence emergency contacts or leave essential responsibilities without agreed cover.

Keep family chat separate from work instructions if everyone finds that useful. Before starting another messaging group, ask who needs it and when replies are expected. Someone who is off duty should not have to infer from a stream of messages whether they have been given another job.

Bring in support without recruiting sides

If the same argument keeps returning, consider a private conversation with someone outside it. The Farming Community Network supports farming people through personal and business difficulties, including family disputes; its volunteers do not provide professional advice.[3] Ask what support fits your circumstances rather than assuming it will mediate a meeting.

FCN’s confidential helpline is 03000 111 999, open daily from 7am to 11pm, with local volunteer support across England and Wales.[3] Before inviting anyone into a family discussion, ask about their role, availability and what information would be shared. You can seek support for yourself without first persuading the whole family to take part.

Fear, threats or controlling behaviour need a different response from an ordinary disagreement. NHS domestic-abuse information includes abuse between family members and routes to specialist help.[6] Do not use these conversation prompts to confront someone you fear; seek support privately using a safe device if needed.

Choose a next step you can actually try

You could write one opening sentence today, request a time to talk or ask a support organisation about its role. If an arrangement is agreed, check back after trying it: did the changed delivery reach the right person, and was the evening boundary respected? For more farming-specific reading, explore the Rural Mind hub.

If you need someone to listen, Samaritans is free on 116 123, day or night.[4] In England, for urgent mental health help, call NHS 111 and choose the mental health option; urgent routes elsewhere in the UK differ.[5] In an emergency, including if you cannot keep yourself or someone else safe, call 999 or go to A&E.[5]

Sources

[1] NHS: Maintaining healthy relationships and mental wellbeing

[2] Mental Health Foundation: Top tips on building and maintaining healthy relationships

[3] Farming Community Network: About FCN

[4] Samaritans: Talk to us on the phone

[5] NHS: Where to get urgent help for mental health

[6] NHS: Getting help for domestic violence and abuse